{
 "chart": "headline/panel3",
 "title": "Models have lower 50% time horizons on TH1.1 and TH2 tasks that we estimate are costlier to make, even controlling for length. The costlier subset is closer to the reported difficulty of OpenAI research use.",
 "subtitle": "Doubling time CIs are calculated by bootstrapping over models, families, and runs. Model CIs are bootstrapped over families and runs. 80% CI intervals are shown as opaque lines and 95% CI intervals as faint lines. For OpenAI's internal research tasks, we fit one 'model' per month and infer a log-normal distribution from its reported CIs.",
 "panels": [
  {
   "title": "50% time horizon by model release date",
   "x": {"label": "Model release date", "unit": "", "scale": "linear"},
   "y": {"label": "50% time horizon", "unit": "minutes", "scale": "log"},
   "tables": [
    {
     "name": "models",
     "rows": [
      {"series": "Lower relative lifecycle cost", "model": "GPT-4o", "released": "2024-05-13", "frontier": true, "horizon_minutes": 11.3484, "horizon_minutes_low_95": 4.45067, "horizon_minutes_high_95": 28.3947, "horizon_minutes_low_80": 6.15308, "horizon_minutes_high_80": 20.8974},
      {"series": "Lower relative lifecycle cost", "model": "o1", "released": "2024-12-05", "frontier": true, "horizon_minutes": 79.4658, "horizon_minutes_low_95": 36.2907, "horizon_minutes_high_95": 151.712, "horizon_minutes_low_80": 48.5801, "horizon_minutes_high_80": 125.179},
      {"series": "Lower relative lifecycle cost", "model": "GPT-5", "released": "2025-08-07", "frontier": true, "horizon_minutes": 349.694, "horizon_minutes_low_95": 153.589, "horizon_minutes_high_95": 746.407, "horizon_minutes_low_80": 205.562, "horizon_minutes_high_80": 578.649},
      {"series": "Lower relative lifecycle cost", "model": "Claude Opus 4.5", "released": "2025-11-24", "frontier": true, "horizon_minutes": 444.37, "horizon_minutes_low_95": 180.053, "horizon_minutes_high_95": 1120.98, "horizon_minutes_low_80": 242.398, "horizon_minutes_high_80": 745.614},
      {"series": "Lower relative lifecycle cost", "model": "Claude Opus 4.6", "released": "2026-02-05", "frontier": true, "horizon_minutes": 710.932, "horizon_minutes_low_95": 234.788, "horizon_minutes_high_95": 4431.9, "horizon_minutes_low_80": 362.297, "horizon_minutes_high_80": 1396.67},
      {"series": "Lower relative lifecycle cost", "model": "GPT-5.4", "released": "2026-03-05", "frontier": false, "horizon_minutes": 661.347, "horizon_minutes_low_95": 291.586, "horizon_minutes_high_95": 1775.65, "horizon_minutes_low_80": 411.978, "horizon_minutes_high_80": 1005.35},
      {"series": "Lower relative lifecycle cost", "model": "Claude Opus 4.7", "released": "2026-04-16", "frontier": true, "horizon_minutes": 732.897, "horizon_minutes_low_95": 282.213, "horizon_minutes_high_95": 3548.78, "horizon_minutes_low_80": 402.938, "horizon_minutes_high_80": 1369.62},
      {"series": "Lower relative lifecycle cost", "model": "GPT-5.5", "released": "2026-04-23", "frontier": true, "horizon_minutes": 783.026, "horizon_minutes_low_95": 345.691, "horizon_minutes_high_95": 1977.14, "horizon_minutes_low_80": 478.904, "horizon_minutes_high_80": 1200.28},
      {"series": "Lower relative lifecycle cost", "model": "Claude Opus 4.8", "released": "2026-05-28", "frontier": true, "horizon_minutes": 966.244, "horizon_minutes_low_95": 319.395, "horizon_minutes_high_95": 12841.7, "horizon_minutes_low_80": 472.403, "horizon_minutes_high_80": 1974.3},
      {"series": "Lower relative lifecycle cost", "model": "Claude Fable 5", "released": "2026-06-09", "frontier": true, "horizon_minutes": 1117.93, "horizon_minutes_low_95": 510.894, "horizon_minutes_high_95": 3353.46, "horizon_minutes_low_80": 683.857, "horizon_minutes_high_80": 1732.93},
      {"series": "Lower relative lifecycle cost", "model": "GPT-5.6 Sol", "released": "2026-07-09", "frontier": false, "horizon_minutes": 845.653, "horizon_minutes_low_95": 354.172, "horizon_minutes_high_95": 2724.59, "horizon_minutes_low_80": 489.16, "horizon_minutes_high_80": 1388.24},
      {"series": "Lower relative lifecycle cost", "model": "Claude Opus 5", "released": "2026-07-24", "frontier": true, "horizon_minutes": 1883.91, "horizon_minutes_low_95": 516.854, "horizon_minutes_high_95": 28116.7, "horizon_minutes_low_80": 730.707, "horizon_minutes_high_80": 6273.23},
      {"series": "Lower relative lifecycle cost", "model": "Claude Fable 5.1", "released": "2026-09-01", "frontier": true, "horizon_minutes": 3531.78, "horizon_minutes_low_95": 780.598, "horizon_minutes_high_95": 40768.5, "horizon_minutes_low_80": 1016.26, "horizon_minutes_high_80": 11019.6},
      {"series": "Lower relative lifecycle cost", "model": "GPT-6 Astra", "released": "2026-09-03", "frontier": true, "horizon_minutes": 4178.14, "horizon_minutes_low_95": 635.896, "horizon_minutes_high_95": 121399.0, "horizon_minutes_low_80": 848.4, "horizon_minutes_high_80": 20888.4},
      {"series": "Lower relative lifecycle cost", "model": "Claude Opus 5.5", "released": "2026-09-22", "frontier": false, "horizon_minutes": 4117.24, "horizon_minutes_low_95": 667.245, "horizon_minutes_high_95": 96423.1, "horizon_minutes_low_80": 909.704, "horizon_minutes_high_80": 17124.6},
      {"series": "Higher relative lifecycle cost", "model": "GPT-4o", "released": "2024-05-13", "frontier": true, "horizon_minutes": 3.67673, "horizon_minutes_low_95": 1.61285, "horizon_minutes_high_95": 7.89033, "horizon_minutes_low_80": 2.1409, "horizon_minutes_high_80": 5.98508},
      {"series": "Higher relative lifecycle cost", "model": "o1", "released": "2024-12-05", "frontier": true, "horizon_minutes": 12.3838, "horizon_minutes_low_95": 2.74573, "horizon_minutes_high_95": 38.0315, "horizon_minutes_low_80": 5.08047, "horizon_minutes_high_80": 27.1387},
      {"series": "Higher relative lifecycle cost", "model": "GPT-5", "released": "2025-08-07", "frontier": true, "horizon_minutes": 86.1899, "horizon_minutes_low_95": 36.9959, "horizon_minutes_high_95": 189.624, "horizon_minutes_low_80": 50.4166, "horizon_minutes_high_80": 150.393},
      {"series": "Higher relative lifecycle cost", "model": "Claude Opus 4.5", "released": "2025-11-24", "frontier": true, "horizon_minutes": 131.754, "horizon_minutes_low_95": 54.993, "horizon_minutes_high_95": 309.804, "horizon_minutes_low_80": 77.2477, "horizon_minutes_high_80": 228.379},
      {"series": "Higher relative lifecycle cost", "model": "Claude Opus 4.6", "released": "2026-02-05", "frontier": true, "horizon_minutes": 169.778, "horizon_minutes_low_95": 68.8411, "horizon_minutes_high_95": 397.697, "horizon_minutes_low_80": 97.8022, "horizon_minutes_high_80": 297.633},
      {"series": "Higher relative lifecycle cost", "model": "GPT-5.4", "released": "2026-03-05", "frontier": true, "horizon_minutes": 179.854, "horizon_minutes_low_95": 75.4787, "horizon_minutes_high_95": 391.639, "horizon_minutes_low_80": 106.129, "horizon_minutes_high_80": 298.877},
      {"series": "Higher relative lifecycle cost", "model": "Claude Opus 4.7", "released": "2026-04-16", "frontier": true, "horizon_minutes": 277.644, "horizon_minutes_low_95": 110.35, "horizon_minutes_high_95": 711.631, "horizon_minutes_low_80": 161.543, "horizon_minutes_high_80": 500.584},
      {"series": "Higher relative lifecycle cost", "model": "GPT-5.5", "released": "2026-04-23", "frontier": true, "horizon_minutes": 512.318, "horizon_minutes_low_95": 214.678, "horizon_minutes_high_95": 23606.2, "horizon_minutes_low_80": 303.821, "horizon_minutes_high_80": 893.586},
      {"series": "Higher relative lifecycle cost", "model": "Claude Opus 4.8", "released": "2026-05-28", "frontier": false, "horizon_minutes": 484.956, "horizon_minutes_low_95": 196.346, "horizon_minutes_high_95": 4897.52, "horizon_minutes_low_80": 283.379, "horizon_minutes_high_80": 826.045},
      {"series": "Higher relative lifecycle cost", "model": "Claude Fable 5", "released": "2026-06-09", "frontier": true, "horizon_minutes": 681.19, "horizon_minutes_low_95": 297.582, "horizon_minutes_high_95": 174169.0, "horizon_minutes_low_80": 416.091, "horizon_minutes_high_80": 1307.13},
      {"series": "Higher relative lifecycle cost", "model": "GPT-5.6 Sol", "released": "2026-07-09", "frontier": false, "horizon_minutes": 572.018, "horizon_minutes_low_95": 246.85, "horizon_minutes_high_95": 76523.6, "horizon_minutes_low_80": 348.745, "horizon_minutes_high_80": 956.523},
      {"series": "Higher relative lifecycle cost", "model": "Claude Opus 5", "released": "2026-07-24", "frontier": true, "horizon_minutes": 769.76, "horizon_minutes_low_95": 369.991, "horizon_minutes_high_95": 3592700.0, "horizon_minutes_low_80": 506.02, "horizon_minutes_high_80": 1208.34},
      {"series": "Higher relative lifecycle cost", "model": "Claude Fable 5.1", "released": "2026-09-01", "frontier": true, "horizon_minutes": 789.719, "horizon_minutes_low_95": 371.987, "horizon_minutes_high_95": 17447900.0, "horizon_minutes_low_80": 512.358, "horizon_minutes_high_80": 1257.3},
      {"series": "Higher relative lifecycle cost", "model": "GPT-6 Astra", "released": "2026-09-03", "frontier": true, "horizon_minutes": 1437.98, "horizon_minutes_low_95": 600.319, "horizon_minutes_high_95": 2014920000.0, "horizon_minutes_low_80": 788.88, "horizon_minutes_high_80": 36322.8},
      {"series": "Higher relative lifecycle cost", "model": "Claude Opus 5.5", "released": "2026-09-22", "frontier": false, "horizon_minutes": 1247.33, "horizon_minutes_low_95": 446.114, "horizon_minutes_high_95": 949639000000.0, "horizon_minutes_low_80": 590.747, "horizon_minutes_high_80": 299358.0}
     ]
    },
    {
     "name": "frontier trends",
     "rows": [
      {"series": "Lower relative lifecycle cost", "from": "2024-05-13", "to": "2026-09-03", "horizon_minutes_from": 15.3562, "horizon_minutes_to": 2483.95, "doubling_months": 3.77451, "doubling_months_low_95": 1.7682, "doubling_months_high_95": 7.04107, "r_squared": 0.95586},
      {"series": "Higher relative lifecycle cost", "from": "2024-05-13", "to": "2026-09-03", "horizon_minutes_from": 3.29295, "horizon_minutes_to": 949.906, "doubling_months": 3.38904, "doubling_months_low_95": 0.845735, "doubling_months_high_95": 4.45576, "r_squared": 0.977089}
     ]
    },
    {
     "name": "OpenAI internal research tasks with zero human interventions",
     "rows": [
      {"month": "2026-03", "horizon_minutes": 36.6961, "horizon_minutes_low_95": 23.7049, "horizon_minutes_high_95": 58.2124},
      {"month": "2026-04", "horizon_minutes": 42.3817, "horizon_minutes_low_95": 27.3291, "horizon_minutes_high_95": 66.7632},
      {"month": "2026-05", "horizon_minutes": 47.1996, "horizon_minutes_low_95": 29.6651, "horizon_minutes_high_95": 77.3211},
      {"month": "2026-06", "horizon_minutes": 61.8272, "horizon_minutes_low_95": 34.7158, "horizon_minutes_high_95": 112.09},
      {"month": "2026-07", "horizon_minutes": 81.8542, "horizon_minutes_low_95": 42.947, "horizon_minutes_high_95": 159.38},
      {"month": "2026-08", "horizon_minutes": 90.9882, "horizon_minutes_low_95": 41.4581, "horizon_minutes_high_95": 196.104},
      {"month": "2026-09", "horizon_minutes": 101.37, "horizon_minutes_low_95": 51.2537, "horizon_minutes_high_95": 195.331},
      {"month": "2026-10", "horizon_minutes": 131.89, "horizon_minutes_low_95": 51.3464, "horizon_minutes_high_95": 320.486}
     ]
    },
    {
     "name": "OpenAI internal research tasks with zero human interventions trend",
     "rows": [
      {"from": "2026-03-15", "to": "2026-10-15", "horizon_minutes_from": 35.4872, "horizon_minutes_to": 129.729, "doubling_months": 3.75952, "doubling_months_low_95": 2.42003, "doubling_months_high_95": 8.99038, "r_squared": 0.984691}
     ]
    }
   ]
  },
  {
   "title": "Doubling times across bootstrap draws",
   "x": {"label": "Months per doubling", "unit": "", "scale": "linear"},
   "y": {"label": "Share of draws", "unit": "", "scale": "linear"},
   "tables": [
    {
     "name": "doubling times across bootstrap draws",
     "rows": [
      {"series": "Lower relative lifecycle cost", "months_from": 0.0, "months_to": 0.25, "share_of_draws": 0.0025},
      {"series": "Lower relative lifecycle cost", "months_from": 0.25, "months_to": 0.5, "share_of_draws": 0.0045},
      {"series": "Lower relative lifecycle cost", "months_from": 0.5, "months_to": 0.75, "share_of_draws": 0.001},
      {"series": "Lower relative lifecycle cost", "months_from": 0.75, "months_to": 1.0, "share_of_draws": 0.0015},
      {"series": "Lower relative lifecycle cost", "months_from": 1.0, "months_to": 1.25, "share_of_draws": 0.003},
      {"series": "Lower relative lifecycle cost", "months_from": 1.25, "months_to": 1.5, "share_of_draws": 0.0065},
      {"series": "Lower relative lifecycle cost", "months_from": 1.5, "months_to": 1.75, "share_of_draws": 0.0055},
      {"series": "Lower relative lifecycle cost", "months_from": 1.75, "months_to": 2.0, "share_of_draws": 0.012},
      {"series": "Lower relative lifecycle cost", "months_from": 2.0, "months_to": 2.25, "share_of_draws": 0.018},
      {"series": "Lower relative lifecycle cost", "months_from": 2.25, "months_to": 2.5, "share_of_draws": 0.021},
      {"series": "Lower relative lifecycle cost", "months_from": 2.5, "months_to": 2.75, "share_of_draws": 0.044},
      {"series": "Lower relative lifecycle cost", "months_from": 2.75, "months_to": 3.0, "share_of_draws": 0.071},
      {"series": "Lower relative lifecycle cost", "months_from": 3.0, "months_to": 3.25, "share_of_draws": 0.0875},
      {"series": "Lower relative lifecycle cost", "months_from": 3.25, "months_to": 3.5, "share_of_draws": 0.115},
      {"series": "Lower relative lifecycle cost", "months_from": 3.5, "months_to": 3.75, "share_of_draws": 0.112},
      {"series": "Lower relative lifecycle cost", "months_from": 3.75, "months_to": 4.0, "share_of_draws": 0.115},
      {"series": "Lower relative lifecycle cost", "months_from": 4.0, "months_to": 4.25, "share_of_draws": 0.0735},
      {"series": "Lower relative lifecycle cost", "months_from": 4.25, "months_to": 4.5, "share_of_draws": 0.0745},
      {"series": "Lower relative lifecycle cost", "months_from": 4.5, "months_to": 4.75, "share_of_draws": 0.0565},
      {"series": "Lower relative lifecycle cost", "months_from": 4.75, "months_to": 5.0, "share_of_draws": 0.0395},
      {"series": "Lower relative lifecycle cost", "months_from": 5.0, "months_to": 5.25, "share_of_draws": 0.0355},
      {"series": "Lower relative lifecycle cost", "months_from": 5.25, "months_to": 5.5, "share_of_draws": 0.0185},
      {"series": "Lower relative lifecycle cost", "months_from": 5.5, "months_to": 5.75, "share_of_draws": 0.0115},
      {"series": "Lower relative lifecycle cost", "months_from": 5.75, "months_to": 6.0, "share_of_draws": 0.015},
      {"series": "Lower relative lifecycle cost", "months_from": 6.0, "months_to": 6.25, "share_of_draws": 0.0115},
      {"series": "Lower relative lifecycle cost", "months_from": 6.25, "months_to": 6.5, "share_of_draws": 0.0075},
      {"series": "Lower relative lifecycle cost", "months_from": 6.5, "months_to": 6.75, "share_of_draws": 0.0065},
      {"series": "Lower relative lifecycle cost", "months_from": 6.75, "months_to": 7.0, "share_of_draws": 0.004},
      {"series": "Lower relative lifecycle cost", "months_from": 7.0, "months_to": 7.25, "share_of_draws": 0.0045},
      {"series": "Lower relative lifecycle cost", "months_from": 7.25, "months_to": 7.5, "share_of_draws": 0.0035},
      {"series": "Lower relative lifecycle cost", "months_from": 7.5, "months_to": 7.75, "share_of_draws": 0.002},
      {"series": "Lower relative lifecycle cost", "months_from": 7.75, "months_to": 8.0, "share_of_draws": 0.002},
      {"series": "Lower relative lifecycle cost", "months_from": 8.0, "months_to": 8.25, "share_of_draws": 0.0025},
      {"series": "Higher relative lifecycle cost", "months_from": 0.0, "months_to": 0.25, "share_of_draws": 0.004},
      {"series": "Higher relative lifecycle cost", "months_from": 0.25, "months_to": 0.5, "share_of_draws": 0.0085},
      {"series": "Higher relative lifecycle cost", "months_from": 0.5, "months_to": 0.75, "share_of_draws": 0.0105},
      {"series": "Higher relative lifecycle cost", "months_from": 0.75, "months_to": 1.0, "share_of_draws": 0.0125},
      {"series": "Higher relative lifecycle cost", "months_from": 1.0, "months_to": 1.25, "share_of_draws": 0.0125},
      {"series": "Higher relative lifecycle cost", "months_from": 1.25, "months_to": 1.5, "share_of_draws": 0.014},
      {"series": "Higher relative lifecycle cost", "months_from": 1.5, "months_to": 1.75, "share_of_draws": 0.0145},
      {"series": "Higher relative lifecycle cost", "months_from": 1.75, "months_to": 2.0, "share_of_draws": 0.017},
      {"series": "Higher relative lifecycle cost", "months_from": 2.0, "months_to": 2.25, "share_of_draws": 0.0165},
      {"series": "Higher relative lifecycle cost", "months_from": 2.25, "months_to": 2.5, "share_of_draws": 0.031},
      {"series": "Higher relative lifecycle cost", "months_from": 2.5, "months_to": 2.75, "share_of_draws": 0.0545},
      {"series": "Higher relative lifecycle cost", "months_from": 2.75, "months_to": 3.0, "share_of_draws": 0.1055},
      {"series": "Higher relative lifecycle cost", "months_from": 3.0, "months_to": 3.25, "share_of_draws": 0.177},
      {"series": "Higher relative lifecycle cost", "months_from": 3.25, "months_to": 3.5, "share_of_draws": 0.196},
      {"series": "Higher relative lifecycle cost", "months_from": 3.5, "months_to": 3.75, "share_of_draws": 0.167},
      {"series": "Higher relative lifecycle cost", "months_from": 3.75, "months_to": 4.0, "share_of_draws": 0.081},
      {"series": "Higher relative lifecycle cost", "months_from": 4.0, "months_to": 4.25, "share_of_draws": 0.0375},
      {"series": "Higher relative lifecycle cost", "months_from": 4.25, "months_to": 4.5, "share_of_draws": 0.018},
      {"series": "Higher relative lifecycle cost", "months_from": 4.5, "months_to": 4.75, "share_of_draws": 0.01},
      {"series": "Higher relative lifecycle cost", "months_from": 4.75, "months_to": 5.0, "share_of_draws": 0.005},
      {"series": "Higher relative lifecycle cost", "months_from": 5.0, "months_to": 5.25, "share_of_draws": 0.003},
      {"series": "Higher relative lifecycle cost", "months_from": 5.25, "months_to": 5.5, "share_of_draws": 0.0015},
      {"series": "Higher relative lifecycle cost", "months_from": 5.5, "months_to": 5.75, "share_of_draws": 0.001},
      {"series": "Higher relative lifecycle cost", "months_from": 5.75, "months_to": 6.0, "share_of_draws": 0.0005},
      {"series": "Higher relative lifecycle cost", "months_from": 6.0, "months_to": 6.25, "share_of_draws": 0.0005},
      {"series": "Higher relative lifecycle cost", "months_from": 6.25, "months_to": 6.5, "share_of_draws": 0.0005},
      {"series": "Higher relative lifecycle cost", "months_from": 6.5, "months_to": 6.75, "share_of_draws": 0.0},
      {"series": "Higher relative lifecycle cost", "months_from": 6.75, "months_to": 7.0, "share_of_draws": 0.0},
      {"series": "Higher relative lifecycle cost", "months_from": 7.0, "months_to": 7.25, "share_of_draws": 0.0},
      {"series": "Higher relative lifecycle cost", "months_from": 7.25, "months_to": 7.5, "share_of_draws": 0.0005},
      {"series": "Higher relative lifecycle cost", "months_from": 7.5, "months_to": 7.75, "share_of_draws": 0.0},
      {"series": "Higher relative lifecycle cost", "months_from": 7.75, "months_to": 8.0, "share_of_draws": 0.0},
      {"series": "Higher relative lifecycle cost", "months_from": 8.0, "months_to": 8.25, "share_of_draws": 0.0}
     ]
    }
   ]
  }
 ]
}
